Mystery Podcasts That Will Scratch Your Detective Itch

Average Rating: 4.5

Hosted by Phoebe Judge, Criminal is a groundbreaking podcast that dives into the lives of those who have done wrong, been wronged, or found themselves caught in murky waters. Lauded as one of the Best Podcasts of 2023 by the New York Times, this show is a fine blend of compelling storytelling and rich character exploration within the true crime genre. Released on March 14, 2025, this podcast is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. You can dive into its chilling narratives here.

Average Rating: 4.5

Step into the shadows with The NoSleep Podcast, an anthology series that has captivated audiences with its original horror stories. This multi-award-winning show incorporates atmospheric music to enhance the chilling tales, making it a perfect listen for fans of suspense and psychological terror. Dive into this menacing auditory experience here.

Average Rating: 4.5

Lore serves as a captivating exploration into dark historical tales, delving into mysterious, tragic events and the unconventional places that dot the map of history. Each episode takes listeners on an eerie journey into the past, uncovering stories that may just make you reconsider what you thought about reality. Experience the blend of history and horror here.

Average Rating: 3.8

Join lifelong friends Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark in My Favorite Murder, where they passionately share their favorite true crime stories and invite listeners to contribute their own hometown crime narratives. With humor interlaced in chilling recounts, this podcast offers a refreshing take on the true crime genre. Listen to their engaging discussions here.

Average Rating: 4.5

Produced by Serial Productions, S-Town transports listeners to Alabama, where a man named John implores journalist Brian Reed to investigate troubling allegations surrounding a wealthy family. As John’s story unfolds, a deeper narrative reveals feuds, hidden treasure, and the complexities of life. Released on October 15, 2024, this podcast offers a multi-layered tale of mystery and human emotion. For a glimpse into this enthralling saga, click here.

Average Rating: 4.5

Dr. Death is a heart-stopping exploration of the medical world’s dark underbelly. Hosted by Laura Beil, this podcast meticulously chronicles the terrifying journey of patients who, believing they were in good hands, faced harrowing realities. From a charming surgeon to malicious betrayal, each season tackles a new, spine-chilling case that will leave you questioning trust in medicine. To immerse yourself further in this shocking series, tune in here.

Average Rating: 4.5

As a podcast that redefined narrative audio storytelling, Serial dives into true crime with rich, layered storytelling that keeps audiences coming back for more. Originally a spinoff of public radio’s “This American Life,” it has since garnered numerous awards and immense popularity. Now part of the New York Times Company, their latest content can be accessed here.

Average Rating: 4.5

With a gripping narrative that blends journalism and horror, The Black Tapes follows journalist Alex Reagan as she investigates a series of supernatural occurrences and the truth behind her subject’s enigmatic history. This serialized docudrama keeps you guessing and questioning, making it a must-listen for fans of the eerie and unexplained. Start your journey into the unknown here.