"This is Judy garland ( at that time ) at her utmost finest! The song “ the man that got away” . Very emotional- Judy put EVERY BIT of herself in her acting in this film. My opinion MUCH better than 3rd version (Barbra Streisand , Kris Kristofferson)"
Jay Titerle
"I'm a fan of all four but nothing beats Judy Garland."
adrienne
"This movie was the first “A Star Is Born” and it’s a real classic. Warning: you might cry. I know I did"
Diamond Baker
"The orig, has a bit more of a classic charm to it than the new one."
Preston Mathis
"i’ve been writing frantically, trying to gather all the thoughts and words this movie rises from me. her voice is truly beautiful, a wonder of her time and the ages following.
“for a chance at being something bigger then ive ever dreamed of. and im not going back now, ever.”"